Holly’s lifelong dream was to fall in love with the perfect guy, so when she meets cynic, Christmas-hater Chris, she’s not interested. That doesn’t stop Holly's Great Aunt Lillian (who is never wrong) from 'pairing' them together—in front of a crowd. Genuine feelings begin to develop for both Chris and Holly, as their friends and family find ways to bring them together, but Holly’s mistakes and Chris’ stubbornness cause a wedge between them that appears too overwhelming to overcome. However, their time together ends up teaching both Chris and Holly important lessons in honesty, family, and love.